SOLAREDGE REVIEW: SOLAREDGE INVERTER AND POWER OPTIMISER
We have been installing SolarEdge inverters and optimizers at SolarHub for nearly 3 years and it’s no secret that we love them. Having installed 8.14MWp (1600 systems) of the stuff in that timeframe, and with several new products hitting the market like the SolarEdge smart panel, we thought it would be good to put our experiences and thoughts down on paper and provide you with a full SolarEdge review.
What makes a good solar inverter?
When we first started supplying and installing solar 8 years ago, the differences between inverters were quite substantial. Some could be installed outside, some couldn’t; conversion efficiencies ranged from 92% to 97% and most inverters had a transformer in them and were quite heavy to lift – how times have changed!
These days your standard string inverters are nearly identical in terms of the claimed feature set. If you took the logo off the top of the spec sheet and sat them side by side you’d be hard pushed to tell the inverters apart. Under the hood however it’s a very different story, and we know from experience that inverters have vastly different build qualities, leading to variable reliability and performance between brands.
Measuring reliability is a highly subjective undertaking and its nearly impossible to get accurate numbers out of manufacturers – they all say their failure rate is less than 1%! Industry veterans also have vastly differing views about what makes a good, reliable inverter and it amazes us how the fantastic experience of one installer can be equalled by the horrible experience of another.
Support from the manufacturer is key
We have had good and bad experiences with nearly all the major inverter brands at some point in that 8 years. However, the most notable aspect is how well the manufacturer supported us when something went wrong. SolarEdge, hands down, are one of the better companies we have dealt with. Their support is one of the reasons we keep supplying their products to our valuable customers and we know, that no matter what the issue, SolarEdge strives to resolve problems promptly and efficiently. That’s one of the reasons we give a positive SolarEdge review.
While support is the number one factor we consider, there are lots of other things we assess when choosing what products to offer our customers (in order of importance):
- Technical support
- Reliability, longevity and quality – these all sort of go together
- Flexibility of the product i.e. the ability to add a battery or connect a hot water system later
- Financial stability of the manufacturer
- Commitment to research and development – how progressive is the manufacturer and are they investing heavily in innovation
- Price (note this one comes last for us)
No manufacturer gets a perfect score, but the best ones get very close and SolarEdge is certainly one manufacturer that does this. This is particularly evident in the areas of flexibility, R&D, safety and support.
Module Level Power Electronics
SolarEdge is a little different to the rest in that uses Module Level Power Electronics (MLPE) to optimise the production of your Solar PV system. This is probably worthy of a blog post itself, but we will try and break it down in simple terms what MLPE does for you and how this differs from your typical string inverter setups.
A typical solar panel contains a group of cells (60 or 72) connected in strings to a junction box mounted at the back of the panel. The junction box holds several bypass diodes which turns parts of the panel off if they are affected by shade. This isolates the effect of the shade to a small part of the panel but unfortunately, in standard solar setups, there is a flow-on effect to the rest of the panels in the system that reduces the overall performance of your solar system beyond just the effect of the shade on one panel.
Standard string inverters minimise the impact of shade by having two Maximum Power Point Trackers (MPPTs) in the inverter. These MPPT’s are continually working throughout the day to strike a balance between voltage and current to maximise the amount of power produced. If there is shade on one or two panels then it does its best to keep the power on that string as high as possible. Most string inverters have 2 of these MPPTs, so if there is shade on an east facing panel in the morning it can be totally isolated from the panels facing north that are in full sun.
Introducing the power optimiser
SolarEdge takes an entirely different approach to this problem by installing a little box called a power optimiser at the back of each panel. These power optimisers mean that rather than being restricted to 2 MPPTs you effectively have an MPPT in the back of every panel, which means each panel produces its maximum power and you get more energy out of your solar system.
In addition to having the MPPT in the back of each panel, these module level power optimisers provide a raft of additional benefits:
- Module level shutdown – when you turn the inverter off the voltage coming from the panels and DC wiring drops down to a safe level (1-volt x the number of panels) rather than the 400V-500V coming from the roof of a typical solar system
- Panel level monitoring – you can see what each panel is doing, and this allows you to track the performance over time – which is essential if you ever have a performance warranty problem down the track
- Longer strings – for reasons we won’t go into now you can connect more panels together in a string and this reduces the number of other components you need on the roof such as DC isolators
- Installation flexibility – you can add any type of panel you like (with some exceptions) in practice across several different orientations and it’s easy to swap panels out for a new model if you have issues down the track (the panel specs don’t have to match)
In summary, MLPE is in our opinion and in our SolarEdge review a superior approach and we think over time we will see it become the standard for solar panels, whether using power optimisers or some other MPLE variant.
Incremental gains are what this industry was built on
Recently, SolarEdge launched their new inverter, with HD-Wave technology which has a conversion efficiency of 99% – a 1.5% efficiency improvement on its predecessor.
These little gains are what has made this industry what it is today. It’s rare to see big leaps in efficiency for any type of electronics, incremental improvements are what drives innovation and keeps this industry moving forward. Inverter efficiency has been stagnant for some time and to see SolarEdge push the boundaries of what’s possible and deliver an inverter capable of a record-breaking 99% weighted conversion efficiency is about a close to perfect as you can get. Another reason SolarEdge get a good review from us.
It’s not a hybrid inverter but its close
We don’t supply hybrid inverters unless you buy a battery, full stop (well OK there are a few exceptions but it’s a fairly hard and fast rule). Who knows what battery types, makes, configurations will be available over the next few years. The technology is moving rapidly and there is no guarantee that you will even be able to add the battery to the hybrid inverter we supply you when it comes time to do so.
But if you don’t buy a hybrid inverter now won’t it cost a lot more later? Well, for most inverters, yes, but for SolarEdge, no. SolarEdge have a neat and comparatively cheap interface that looks a bit like this:
You simply tack this StorEdge interface on to the side of your inverter and connect it to your battery and you are away. The key difference here between the SolarEdge approach and the approach from other manufacturers is that you don’t need another inverter. The interface box is just what is says it is, an interface, with a small amount of electronics in it that allows your standard SolarEdge inverter to talk to the battery.
DC coupling is a better option
The other great advantage of this approach is that all the charging happens without converting any of the electricity to AC – it is what is commonly known as “DC Coupling”. DC Coupling is a fantastic little way to maximise the size of the system you can install at your house, as most grid connection limitations apply to the AC output of your inverter not the number of solar panels (DC) you install. To explain this in more detail look at the following graph for a system that has a 6kW SolarEdge inverter and 9.6kW of LG 300W MonoX panels:
If you look at the green line, which is the total output of the solar panels (noting it’s the middle of a Canberra winter), you can see the power peaks well above 6kW. So how is this happening given it’s only a 6kW inverter? Well, quite simply, the excess DC electricity coming from your panels is going straight into the battery (the red line) meaning the battery is charged more quickly. No conversion to AC (which incurs electrical losses) and no knock back from the local network operator (who mandate a 5kW AC limit but have provided us with special dispensation to use a 6kW inverter if we ask nicely).
Smart homes, device monitoring and hot water control
One of the other great things about getting yourself a SolarEdge inverter is that you can trick it up with several other little gadgets that reduce your energy bills even further and give you greater visibility and control over power hungry devices in your home. Here are some of the smart energy devices now available:
|Smart Energy Hot Water||This is a wireless controller which automatically diverts surplus PV energy to provide hot water. It is a particular cost-effective way to store excess solar energy. The great thing about this unit is that it ramps the power up and down depending on how much excess solar you have.|
|Smart Energy Relay||A wireless switch that controls various loads such as air-conditioners or hot water heat pumps. This allows you to use more of you solar energy and manage your appliance via your phone|
We anticipate several more Smart Home or Smart Energy products to hit the market from SolarEdge over the coming years. It’s an area that is starting to attract a lot of interest from homeowners wanting to control everything from lights, to the charging of their EV to switching on appliances when its more financially beneficial for them to do so. The nice thing about SolarEdge’s approach here is that all these components are just add-ons, you can install them now or later and other than the component itself and a little ZigBee card that goes in the inverter, there is no more that needs to be done.
Buying solar should be no harder than buying a car
There are so many different pieces that go into a solar system and we feel for people that are looking to buy a system for the first time, it must be daunting! This isn’t like buying a car where you drop down to your local dealer and grab a Hyundai, Toyota or a Lexus, sign up for some finance and walk out the door with the keys – buying solar is a very involved process that requires the average buyer to somehow decide between an array of brands, suppliers and installers and sit the first year of an electrical engineering degree along the way.
As it stands now, a typical solar system comprises of at least 10 different brands of equipment. You might have LG for your panels, SolarEdge for your inverter, BYD for your battery, Clenergy for your racking system, Hager for your electrical components, Reposit for your battery control system, EDMI for you meter…the list goes on. It can be a very confusing and complicated process with a lot of different brands to consider.
Whether the manufacturer you are buying from physically makes all the components or not is irrelevant (Hyundai don’t make all the components for a car I can assure you). What matters here is that when buying one brand you have one company providing your warranty, one company to go back to if you have an issue and you don’t get stuck in limbo between manufacturers pretending an issue is not of their making. Imagine if the glue on your new car door frame started failing and you had to call Bostik to come out and fix it under warranty – it would be very frustrating and quite ridiculous really. SolarEdge are looking to change this experience and while its not quite like buying a car yet, its certainly headed in that direction.
SolarEdge diversifying is a good thing
Several commentators have suggested that perhaps SolarEdge is losing focus on their core product by offering panels, smart home devices and EV chargers but from where we sit as a supplier and installer we think it’s a fantastic move by SolarEdge. By diversifying and offering a wider range of interconnected products they are simplifying the process of buying solar or energy storage for customers and cutting out some of the complexity for suppliers like ourselves that are installing, configuring and supporting the system.
Good on SolarEdge for cutting through the complexity, creating a holistic solution in which all the produces are designed to work together, and diversifying their range to provide an end-to-end solution customers are crying out for. The new inverters with HD-Wave technology are a fantastic little unit and our installers like not breaking their backs lifting the 10kg units onto the wall. We can’t wait to see what SolarEdge announce next!